Wednesday, July 31, 2019

What culture is right for you?

THE PROBLEM
During 2005-2006 with the implementation of a pioneer-settler-town planner structure in a high tech startup in Old Street, London (a barren wasteland of technology at that time), one noted observation was that the different components of the structure appeared to have different cultures. A more recent set of observations (2014-2016), through examination of company’s doctrine has shown us that the principles used in companies are not the same and not even necessarily uniform within a company and this appears to impact the adaptability of the organisation.

To put it simply, if I take a list of universally useful principles derived from mapping (see figure 1) and then compare companies with a simple traffic light system (are you good at this or not) then differences exist (figure 2 and 3).

Figure 1 - Doctrine, a list of universally useful principles.



Figure 2 - Doctrine within a Web Giant


Figure 3 - Doctrine within a Banking Giant



Now, we cannot say which principles matter more and the doctrine list itself is constantly expanding. For example, as technology evolves then there is a constant co-evolution of practice and some of those practices are instead universally useful principles i.e. focus on user needs or use appropriate methods (i.e. XP vs Lean vs Six Sigma).  

It's worth unpacking this a bit more. Practice itself tends to be tied with a specific implementation of an underlying systems i.e. best architectural practice for compute as a product included disaster recovery tests and capacity planning. The practice itself evolves - it doesn't appear fully formed - and hence we have novel, emerging, good and best practice i.e. all four stages of any evolving capital (see figure 4).

Figure 4 - The stages of capital and the labels we use.

When technology evolves, a novel practice can co-evolve due to some characteristic change. In the shift from Compute as a Product (stage III, see figure 4 above) to Compute as a Utility (stage IV, see figure 4 above) then the characteristic that changed was MTTR (mean time to recovery). In the old world, when a server went bang it could take months to get a new machine. In the new world, it can take seconds.  This allowed for a new set of practices (which we labelled, overtime, as DevOps) and included design for failure, continuous deployment, distributed systems and chaos engines (random introduction of failure into the system). Such practices then themselves evolved and are now considered good (becoming best) architectural practice for compute as a utility.

This is best seen with a map, hence I've highlighted the process in figure 5. It's worth noting that a major form of inertia to a change of an underlying technology are the best practices that existed with the less evolved technology. It's not just pre-existing capital (i.e. sunk cost) that causes a resistance to change (such as shift from product to utility) but also the practices associated with the past way of doing things.

Figure 5 - A map of co-evolution with technology.


Sometimes, within the maelstrom of a changing technology there emerges a set of practices that transcend the context and are universally useful i.e. focus on user needs or think small i.e. know the details.  Sometimes these practices are hidden in more context specific practices i.e thinking small hidden in both micro services and the use of cell based structures. These practices are not dependent upon the underlying technology and the specific context.  These practices we call universally useful principles and doctrine is simply a collection of universally useful principles. The appearance of such principles is often by happenstance or as a process of people rethinking how we do stuff.  The principles do have a contextual side to them i.e. my user needs are not necessarily the same as your user needs but overall a focus on user needs is seen as universally beneficial.

However, what matters in competition is also your competition. Being hopeless at these principles doesn't matter as long as your competitors are the same. If we all ignore user needs then no-one gains any advantage. It only becomes a problem when a different style of company (such as the Web Giant) enters our industry (i.e. Banking). Finally, within a single company these principles aren't even uniform. Some parts may well have a different style of leadership and a different emphasis.

Overall, these statements should not be surprising - "cultures and related principles are different between organisations and within organisations and this may have an impact on performance".

Unfortunately, this leads us to a question of “What culture is right for you”. The problem with that question is in its unpacking.

WHAT CULTURE IS RIGHT FOR YOU?
Firstly, we have to define what culture is in order to distinguish between what maybe right or maybe wrong? In 1952, the American anthropologists, Kroeber and Kluckhohn, critically reviewed concepts and definitions of culture in the academic world and compiled a list of 164 different definitions. Any review of popular business press shows the term is equally, if not more so nebulous today. Despite this, we assign almost mystical properties and powers to “culture” with memes such as “culture eats strategy for breakfast”.

The subject matter itself is complicated in terms of many different components that influence it from learned to inherited behaviours, from both social to personal constructs, from layers to manifestations, from determinism to relativism, from the semantic to symbolic history. It is also complex in that many of its attributes appear emergent as with many evolving processes. The field is also littered in business press with many inadequate concepts that do no hold up well to scrutiny such as the idea that culture is homogenous (as in one thing), that it is evenly distributed among members of any social group (including organisations), that individuals possess just a single culture or that culture is simply custom or that somehow culture is fixed rather than transient and timeless.

At best, we can say that culture contains many things from experience, learned behaviour, knowledge, meanings, relationships, hierarchies (i.e. power structures), capabilities (i.e. skills), values, possessions, aspects of belief (i.e. ethical position relative to others), principles and attitudes. It has many layers from the individual to the group to the organisation to the nation. It has many perspectives which may vary with context.

In terms of the question, the problems with it can be stated as follows :-

1) with the word “culture” and its definition.
2) with the words “what is right” as this requires some measure of what is right and acceptance that there may be many rights and many wrongs both of which may change with context.
3) with the words “for you” as there are many perspectives. There is also the derived implication that culture can be directed because there is no point in knowing what's right if you can't get there. The issue here, is that many parts may only be ever emergent i.e. we might be able to nudge but can't force a direction.

This mess of a subject however does not prevent a thriving and lucrative industry of self-help guides, performance value matrices, eight or ten step processes and declarations of what makes a successful culture - short term wins, empowering employees, establishing a sense of urgency, communicating the vision, from good to great matrices etc. Most disturbingly, many of the characteristics described as associated with success often through positive case examples can equally be found in those that failed. This also leads to a notorious problem of outcome bias where we adopt some approach simply because others we see as successful have used that approach and finally confirmation bias where the evidence that such an approach works is that others are now adopting it. This seems to lead to an endless barrage of memes and the desire to get "big names" to bless some approach. 

From my personal experience, the net result of an extensive reading of business press left me with one of two paths, either join some cult of belief around the latest management guru or throw my hands up in horror and retire to the marsh I inhabit. Fortunately, anthropology came to the rescue. The single distinguishing difference between anthropology and the business press when it comes to the issue of culture is that anthropology is observation led and focuses to minute detail on observation whereas the popular business press seems to start with a hypothesis and find case examples to fit it.

This question of observation provides me with a route into the field, because maps are all about observation. The very start of the strategy cycle (figure 6) is the first O of OODA - observation, from which contexts can be learned and patterns discovered then reapplied.

Figure 6 - The Strategy Cycle.


CAN WE MAP CULTURE?
It's not just activities and practice that evolve. From figure 4 above, we could map knowledge as a form of capital. As a primitive example, I've added a quick map of population genetics using the knowledge axis. Now, you might disagree with how evolved the components are, you might add additional components that are missing but that's the point of maps. Our evolving higher order systems are built upon evolving lower order components whether activities, practices, data or knowledge.

Figure 7 - Population Genetics as Knowledge.


In the same way, we have to accept that culture has many components rather than being one thing. It is a construct built on constructs. The question is, can those components be mapped or can mapping help? We already know that mapping has proved useful in terms of understanding a competitive landscape, investigation of practices, determining what appear to be commonly useful principles (i.e. doctrine) and examination of other forms of capital (i.e. knowledge or data). Maps inherently have perspective and many layers can be used from the individual to the nation state. Maps are designed around the concepts of evolution and for this reason maps can assist with both the complicated and the complex (emergent behaviours).  Maps are a context aware mechanism of communication and learning for both past actions and potential future behaviours. 

At first glance, these concepts of context and of universal patterns appear to chime well with the ideas of culture. We already have some fair advanced thinking on landscape, on doctrine and on inertia. We can even expose attitude through organisational structures such as Pioneers - Settler - Town Planner.  But there are limitation with maps. The technique is imperfect (all maps, in order to be useful, have to be imperfect representations). We also know that maps themselves can change behaviour, from the tackling of bias to inertia. Maps have the potential to be a visible artefact of culture and as much a part of the landscape as a means of visualising it.  The most severe limitation is that maps depend upon evolution of capital.

However, ideas, the meanings between them and even our values and ethical constructs evolve. In Edgar Schein’s Organisational Culture : A dynamic model he directly refers to the changing nature of value from espoused values to assumptions to unconscious responses.

In mapping terms, a similar evolutionary scale can be acquired by combining the labels from different forms of capital (across practices, data and knowledge). Taking figure 4 above, I've highlighted the following labels (figure 8) to provide a scale of  :-

Stage  I: Concept (and observation) - an espoused value.
Stage  II : Emerging - the evolution of an espoused value as an emerging theme.
Stage III : Converging - the conflict between emerging themes to form an assumption or an array of assumptions
Stage IV : Accepted - the unconscious response when the once espoused value has become an accepted norm and taken for granted.

Figure 8 - Labels for ethical values.
As with any form of capital, we can simply map this and combine it with other forms of capital. Using the ubiquitous cup of tea example, we can add to the discussion not only the physical components, any practices, any knowledge, any flow of capital (i.e. finance) but also considerations of value and ethics such as fair trading or green energy (see figure 9). In this figure I've changed the x-axis (in red) to the labels used for discussing ethical capital.

Figure 9 - Expanding the cup of tea.


Since the labels on the x-axis are simply notations for stage I to IV of capital, I have provided the alternative labels in the figure above but normally, I just use the labels for activities (from genesis to utility) as in figure 10 whether I'm talking about activities, practice, data, knowledge or even ethical values. This provides a good enough representation for me.

Figure 10 - A normal map including ethical values.


Since mapping itself is derived from the strategy cycle, it is inherent in maps that the existing state is derived from looping around the cycle i.e. past action informs the present. This would mean that culture (as with other forms of capital) in an organisation would not only be a set of evolving components that interact but also a consequence of past actions (i.e. loops). The choices of today being limited by past contexts and decisions. This means that culture cannot be measured against some standard because it is dependant upon the landscape, varies with history and is inherently emergent in the same way that strategy is. 

However, this doesn’t mean patterns don’t exist and hence the same climatic patterns (rules of the game), context specific patterns (methods of manipulating certain contexts) and universally useful principles (i.e. doctrine) can exist. 

Finally, mapping does distinguish between the needs (it describe a chain of needs in a landscape) versus the want (i.e. often how we wish to influence or manipulate the landscape). This difference of wants and needs is also present in culture i.e. the a set of generic wants of the poor and the middle class might be identical but the needs can be very different. All has a cultural bearing when it comes to describing a landscape.

NEXT STEPS
Though all maps are an imperfect representation of a space, they have uses in communication, learning and pattern recognition. Some of the components of culture (whether principles or attitudes or ethical values) can be mapped with the assumption of values evolving as described above. Some of the components of today's culture are a consequence of past choices in past landscape. In the same way that we have technical debt to past choices and inertia to change from past success, we should also see cultural debt and inertia to change from ethical capital.

Of course, I've specifically focused on activities (one type of capital) with a particular reference to technology in this discussion whereas co-evolution can occur with many forms of capital i.e. co-evolution of practices (and hence the appearance of principles) can occur due to evolving knowledge or data or even practices themselves (in a delightful recursive twist).

This, however, is a dangerous line of inquiry. As we already know, competitive markets can be easily mapped and manipulated through gameplay from a local industry to nation state. The problem is not can we map and manipulate the culture of a local organisation to create some favourable change as we can simply do this by giving someone the list of doctrine and ask them to examine the company. The problem is can we manipulate the ethical values of a wider system such as a nation state once we have mapped it?

For over a decade, I've been hesitant to explain more on this topic. Times have changed though. Mapping has spread enough that I should open the door a bit more.

240 comments:

«Oldest   ‹Older   201 – 240 of 240
thomas said...


Get Your Error and Problem Solve With QuickBooks Expert 24*7 live.
Dial Quickbooks Support Phone Number to get in touch for
Dial : 1-844-514-7111.

vijay said...




192.168.0.1

192.168.l0.1 Router login

https://www-1921681254.com This IP address is used by the routers like TP-Link, Netgear, D-Link uses it as the default IP address.

meldaresearch said...

Finding the social psychology coursework writing services and Social Psychology Writing Services is not easy unless one is keen to establish a reputable social psychology assignment writing service provider & social psychology research writing services.

yahoo mail customer support said...

Know here how to recover the Yahoo Email.Follow the steps to Yahoo Email Recovery.If you have forgotten your Yahoo mail password, you can easily reset the password again and assess your account. You can change Yahoo Email Recovery or Reset Yahoo password.You need to fill the form and our experts will get back to you for you to Yahoo Email Recovery.

Shopclues Winner List said...

Shopclues prize department here an offer you can win check here the Shopclues prize department 2020 and Shopclues prize list. Here you Shopclues lucky draw and you can find special offers.
Shopclues prize department
Shopclues prize department 2020
Shopclues prize list
Shopclues prize list 2020
Shopclues winner name
Shopclues winner name 2020

Roku com link said...

There are a lot of discounts and deals that you can also enjoy with the help of a Roku activation link. Just enter it and get to select from more than 1000 channels. Roku com link offers you a wide range of music, movie and other channel options.TV viewing was never so much fun, but with Roku, at your service, it will be a great time pass. Make your family sit together and much on to popcorns while watching a movie or groove with them on their favourite songs with Roku.If you still face any problem, then you can reach us at 1-844-412-9807 our experts are available 24*7 to help you out
Roku activation link
Roku com link
activate Roku code
Roku setup
Roku TV activate
https://rokuactivationlinkcom.wordpress.com/

Lucas Miller said...

Skipped your Matlab classes because of other commitments of a busy job schedule? You don’t have to worry. At Matlab Assignment Help we offer tuition to ensure that you catch up with your classmates or even understand the area you did not understand in class. We offer classes based on your topics of need and we work based on your schedule. Our Matlab Homework Help team is available to ensure that your grades are soaring high.

Lucas Miller said...

In my statistics class, we are at the point where we are discussing the log-rank tests. That is the topic of survival analysis. I started well on the topic and understood the Kaplan-Meier test but had a problem with understanding the log-rank test. Perhaps as an experienced statistics homework help expert, you could help me with it. I am adding another assignment to it on SAS. The SAS one is not very urgent because it is due in one month, however, it is quite complex, and therefore I will need a highly experienced SAS assignment help expert.

Lucas Miller said...

Have you centralized your work? I want a programming assignment help expert from Canada. If you have one from this side of the world, I am going to take your C++ assignment help today to have my C++ assignment completed. I do not have much time to do it and that is why I am seeking professional assistance in order to have high grades. Let me know whether you have one. If none then you can let me know whether there is one from a country close to Canada.

Frank Miller said...

Sometimes I feel like the prices these guys charge for Matlab assignment help are too high compared to other sites. But don’t get me wrong, their Matlab assignment helpers are great at what they do. They actually helped me score an A in my control systems assignments. I just feel they should try bring the prices down a little bit.

Frank Miller said...

Which is the best software for statistics homework help? There is so much software that can be used for statistics. But I can't learn how to use all of them. I desire to be a master in statistical software that is considered the best. Which software should I learn for doing my statistics homework? More to that, where can I get SAS assignment help?

Frank Miller said...

After having three amazing years of taking programming assignment help from you, last week I had a bad experience when I came to you for C++ assignment help. I was given a different tutor from the ones I have been working with. I assumed all would be well since in the past all tutors I got had proved to be amazing. This new tutor was very poor in communication and in most cases he was even not available. Within 3 days I was already tired of him because he was not even sending work progress. I simply had to launch a complaint with the customer care team. After I launched the complaint it’s when he rushed to my inbox to tell me that my work was in progress. I refused to work with him and requested for a new tutor.

glendadavis said...

Textbooks are one of the oldest tools available for education. College textbook solutions are deemed the best material to achieve top grades in record time for all students. Scholar On is a great website offering instant access to textbook answers online.

glendadavis said...

Textbooks are one of the oldest tools available for education. College textbook solutions are deemed the best material to achieve top grades in record time for all students. Scholar On is a great website offering instant access to textbook answers online.

kashifkhatri said...


Reviews of the Top 6 Cuckold Dating Sites, cuckold websites Are you cuckold singles looking for like minded cuckold couples for making your cuckold dating fantasy? Let a husband watches both of you and his wife doing sex

unknown said...

thanks for the information, i really like your post infact i have a nice reading experience i have a complete guide on how to set up donations on youtube

Mason Lee said...

Matlab is one of the most demanded units in engineering. However many students avoid it because it is seen as a difficult topic. We are however here to ensure that you get the best Matlab Assignment Help to raise your grade as well as improving your market value. To have your Matlab assignments completed on time visit Matlab Homework Help.

Mason Lee said...

Do you guys have specialized people to handle C assignments or are they the same programming assignment
help
experts who handle java and all other programming assignments? I have started my PhD and I am focusing a lot on C Programming. I am therefore looking for a C assignment help specialist. I have someone who has mastered C from all dimensions. If possible I want a Ph.D. graduate. Tell me if it’s possible so that I can look somewhere else if it’s not possible.

Mason Lee said...

Please give me your view on this quote that I got while studying a book on data analysis ‘there are three kinds of lies, lies, damned lies, and statistics.’ I met this quote on a pdf book on using Microsoft Excel for data analysis. I feel like it's somehow discouraging me from studying statistics. I know that this is not within your context of statistics homework help services, but it's still something worth discussing. I have also heard that most statistics students fail SAS. I would also like to know how true that is and if it is true whether you are going to offer me SAS assignment help for my assignments.

Mason Lee said...

How do you treat urgent assignments? I need an economics assignment help expert in a position to deliver my order in 5 hours. It is very urgent and I am willing to pay extra cash if you are ready to deliver on time. I also want you to concentrate on quality too. If you can deliver it then reach out to me. Let me also know how much you charge for economics homework help.

liza martinee said...

Thank you for posting such a wonderful post. This should be an inspiration to the readers who are actually reading this post.

office.com/setup

unknown said...

nice post, it is really amazing to see what you are doing, I really appreciate your skills
smart way to keep your body fit

unknown said...


I am very happy that I find your post to be very helpful and informative, the content in the post is neat , I will recommend this to my peers thank you free cars for college students

Tekniko Global said...

mobile app development company in Delhi

Rajesh Verma said...

Thanks for your article. It was interesting and informative.
Here I also want to suggest your reader who usually travels one place to another they must visit Airlines Gethuman that offer best deals to book your seat on Delta Airlines Reservations. So do hurry and avail the best deals and get rid of to check different websites for offers.
Get more help on
Southwest Airlines Flights

Rajesh Verma said...

Thanks for your article. It was interesting and informative.
Here I also want to suggest your reader who usually travels one place to another they must visit Airlines Gethuman that offer best deals to book your seat on Delta Airlines Reservations. So do hurry and avail the best deals and get rid of to check different websites for offers.
Get more help on
Southwest Airlines Flights

Southwest Airlines Reservations said...

Thanks for your article. It was interesting and informative.
Here I also want to suggest your reader who usually travels one place to another they must visit Airlines Gethuman that offer best deals to book your seat on Delta Airlines Reservations. So do hurry and avail the best deals and get rid of to check different websites for offers

Southwest Airlines Reservations

Ethan Smith said...

I have gone through your economics assignment help website and it is looking good. I have seen that you have very many tutors, some of who are very highly rated. Can I be allowed to choose a tutor on my own or do you choose the assignments to tutors from your side? I have seen an economics homework help professor with a very good rating and I would want him to handle my work.

Ethan Smith said...

I was not able to communicate properly with the matlab assignment help expert assigned to me earlier for my numerical methods assignment. He was not comfortable with English, so I Asked for another Matlab homework help expert. Please go through your mail to find the assignment you need to work on. Please let me know when I expect the solution.

Ethan Smith said...

I need statistics homework help experts to help me with this. The Pareto distribution is closely related to the exponential distribution. Given X is a strict Pareto random variable, shows that Y = lin(X) is exponentially distributed with mean 1/𝝰. Please provide me a solution to it. If the assignment is done to my satisfaction I have other upcoming assignments. In one I will need a very experienced econometrics assignment help to exert while the other one is on excel which I assume would be simpler.

Ethan Smith said...

Can someone give you their class login so that you can be checking for assignments, complete them, and submit back? I need several programming assignment help experts but to start I need C Assignment help. Once the C one is completed successfully then I will let you handle all my class assignments. I am open to discussion about payments but before that let me know about your availability.

Devin Ronan said...

If this is genuine then you are doing a good job. Offering students economics assignment help is amazing because economics is such a broad subject. I struggled with it during my undergraduate but I finally finished. I am now comfortable that I can get economics homework help from you whenever I am stuck.

Devin Ronan said...

What a lucky week I had with you guys. I got a loyal customer discount by having my signal processing task completed at half price. I however believe I deserved it having taken your Matlab assignment help in my past 8 tasks. I don’t know how the discounting system from you works but at least I got it and I am grateful. Am sending a new assignment and therefore I want the best Matlab homework help solver to complete it. I would be very happy to get another discount.

Devin Ronan said...

Hey there, as an experienced statistics homework help expert do you handle all statistics topics such as R programming, SPSS, Excel, econometrics, and SAS assignment help? If yes please provide me with a hint on how to solve the following question?

Suppose that two batteries are randomly chosen without replacement from the following group of 12 batteries:
3 new
4 used (working)
5 defective
Let X denote the number of new batteries chosen.
Let Y denote the number of used batteries chosen.

Devin Ronan said...

I worked with you four years ago on different programming assignment help tasks. I still remember the C assignment help expert who did my paper in 6 hours. I graduated and I am working well. I am now tasked at work to develop a program for our accounting system which can track invoices. I am wondering whether you people do tasks outside classwork. If you do then I would be very happy to hire you on this one. Give me feedback as fast as you can.

William said...

All the time I found something new information from your blogs. Thanks for sharing .
hey... Great work . I feel nice while i reading blog .You are doing well. Keep it up. We will also provide QuickBooks Customer Service Contact us +1 877-751-0742 for instant help.

William said...

Thanks For Sharing!
We will also provide QuickBooks Customer Service to reach us call to 1-855-756-1077 for immediate help.

John Deo said...

Get 24x7 live support for everything AOL. Included in your membership at no additional cost, AOL 24x7 Live Support provides you with access to AOL experts any time you need them.
Call an AOL 24x7 Live Support experts now to get assistance with technical issues and questions related to your AOL service. Visit Here to Get Support for AOL Desktop Gold Email Desktop Gold

pogo support said...

If you have any yahoo problems that are bothering you for long? You are needed to contact Yahoo Email Phone Number right at the moment you encounter any of problems or glitches. Here at Yahoo Mail Customer Service you can get all the answers to the question, which has been dedicatedly created for yahoo users.
Yahoo Phone Number

sagar said...

Airlines-gethuman.org is a platform where you can Find Contact Information for all the airlines, Assistance with booking your flights, and vacation packages easily. It helps you to save both, your money and your time.


Southwest Airlines Reservations

Southwest Airlines Flights

«Oldest ‹Older   201 – 240 of 240   Newer› Newest»