Wednesday, October 31, 2018

What is an expert

(draft)

I often see examples where people add characteristics to a map or use new definitions for one of the axis. There's nothing wrong with this and I want to encourage people to explore. One recent effort by Manish has the axis as Rookie to Expert which leads to the question - what is an expert?

A map (and I have an entire creative commons book on this, if you want to know more) is a map of capital. The nodes are stocks of capital and the lines are flows of capital. On the x-axis, I normally use the labels for activities - genesis, custom, product (+rental), commodity (+utility).  But you can map not only activities but practices, data and knowledge. We use different terms for each stage of evolution of these forms of capital which for reference I've included in the table below.

All of these forms of capital have common characteristics as they evolve.  These characteristics are captured in the cheat sheet, which even after nearly a decade, I still find to be a useful tool though to be honest, it's embedded deep in my mind these days.



So what has this got to do with expertise? Well, let us take a grossly simple map of healthcare starting with the public and assuming some form of Government sponsored healthcare system. One of the components is treatment but treatment isn't a static thing. There is constant range of new treatments produced whilst the once remarkable becomes routine, even dull. 


So, what do we mean by expertise? Well an expert could be someone who is experienced in a broad range of treatments. They would be a generalist or an expert in general practice.


 But an expert could equally be someone who has specialised in a particular area e.g. the novel study of epigenetic cures or even appendicitis. This person would be a specialist



What is important to understand is that every node on a map can in fact be itself a map.  For example, if we expand out Appendicitis into its own map (see below), there will be many components involved in its treatment. A specialist would have in depth knowledge of each of those components.


Now, you might ask me why the nodes on the last map have no labels. Well, it's because I don't know what they are. I've just added some node and links as a way of saying - there will be components involved but I have no idea what they are. If you actually want a map for it then you'll need to talk to an expert on the subject.

The only people who can actually map a space are those with expertise in that space. In the same way, the only people who can draw you a map of London (even a crude one) are people who have either been to London (physically or virtually) or seen a map.

The beauty of maps is we can have many experts (both generalists and specialists), sharing and communicating with each other through the use of maps and hence improving them. This leads to  best thing about maps. For a rookie like me, then a map is the fastest way I know of bringing me upto speed of a complex and complicated environment. It's also the fastest way of discovering just how little I know.

16 comments:

Jay Jonna Jameson said...

Here is a guide on a compare and contrast paper writing for those who might be interested.

Unknown said...

Great visual examples to the explanation, the last one stole my heart, actually. I've seen something familiar at https://writemyessay4me.org/blog/get-harvard, this source gives useful tips how to improve writing and get entry to any great college.

bbbbbb said...

The way you start your essay would tell a teacher more than you think! Follow this link and learn how to make it better thanks here and
connecting internet not working


Service Center Philips said...

Lampung
youtubeyoutubeyoutubelampungtokoJasalampunglampungyoutube

Service Center Philips said...

Lampung
youtubeyoutubeyoutubelampungtokoJasalampunglampungyoutube

Joey Williams said...

Thank you so much for sharing this post, I appreciate your work.
norton.com/setup
norton.com/setup
mcafee.com/activate
office.com/setup
www.office.com/setup
office.com/setup

norton.com/setup said...

I really happy found this website eventually. Really informative and inoperative, Thanks for the post and effort! Please keep sharing more such blog.

norton.com/setup

norton.com/setup

norton.com/setup

roadrunner email

mcafee.com/activate

aol mail

norton-setup said...

Hello, I'm Smith Warner. If you are facing issues with mcafee(mcafee.com/activate), norton(norton.com/setup) and office(office.com/setup) product. then you can visit my website.

Melani Sugiono said...

13win Situs Agen Judi Online terbaik dan terpercaya di indonesia yang memberikan permainan judi terbaik dari pasarannya, seperti poker online dan bola terbaik dengan nilai kemenangan tertinggi dibandingkan situs lainnya lainnya. Untuk mengenal 13win lebih dekat berikut profile dari 13win https://skupnost.sio.si/blog/index.php?userid=187829/

Geek Squad Support said...

This is the absolutely very first time I see right here. I placed many satisfying things on your blog site, especially its conversation. From the deals of reviewing your fast evaluations, I think I am not the just one having all the pleasure below! Maintain the amazing.

if you have any queries related to your hardware devices like more mobiles, laptop then easily contact our pageGeek squad support we provide the best solution for our customer.

waston said...


I am a web developer and software engineer currently living in the United States. My interests range from technology to causes. I am also interested in running.You can click the button above to view my listings. If you’d like to get in touch, feel free to say hello through any of the website links below.
norton.com/setup
norton.com/nu16
office.com/setup

smith warner said...

Mcafee.com/activate - McAfee Retail Card activation at www mcafee com/activate, enter your product key for Download, Install and activate McAfee Antivirus Software.
Norton.com/setup - Protect your Pc/laptop and other devices with best Norton setup Antivirus. Get security against spyware, malware and viruses. Download Now at www.norton.com/setup.
office.com/setup - Download Setup, Redeem Product Key and Install Office on your computer from www.office.com/setup with Microsoft Account.

Swethagauri said...

Thanks a lot very much for the high quality and results-oriented help. I won’t think twice to endorse your blog post to anybody who wants and needs support about this area.free zone in dubai

kompanyservices said...

The great service in this blog and the nice technology is visible in this blog. I am really very happy for the nice approach is visible in this blog and thank you very much for using the nice technology in this blogcompany incorporation in uae

smith warner said...

Mcafee.com/activate – Get McAfee 25 digit Activation key to set up McAfee protection on your device. Visit www.mcafee.com/activate and follow the step-by-step guide to uninstall, download, install and activate McAfee Antivirus for your PC.
Norton.com/setup - Buy the Norton product and then login to Norton account for downloading the setup. After installing it, navigate to www.norton.com/setup for activating it using the product key.
office.com/setup ,Get Started. Setup & Install Microsoft Office Product Key from the official website. Visit www.office.com/setup and Follow the Instructions.

Unknown said...

Great content, thanks a lot!If your readers are interested in monitoring apps then here are some reviews of the sms tracking apps