Sunday, December 31, 2006

Shout, shout ... let it all out.

Wandering as I was through the local sprawl of shops, I chanced upon a small book "What is your dangerous idea". It piqued my interest, so I bought it. The book is a collection of ideas about the future, it's cute, speculative and generally interesting. As with all good books, it led me on a journey.

The journey in this case, was because of its claim to provide "today's leading thinkers on the unthinkable". How do you define "today's leading thinkers?" One of the lessons that Cambridge taught me was that true genius is very scarce. I was there, and I'm a fully paid up member of the dazzlingly daft society. Along with 90% of the population, I believe I'm above average intelligence which either means I can't count or I'm deluded - I prefer to think I'm deluded. The one thing this does tell me is that I'm not one of the great thinkers, but fortunately I've got a lot of people to keep me company.

The truly great thinkers are often hidden away in the most obscure places and in my experience they never think of themselves in such terms. Now if you are a truly exceptional individual, let's say in the top 0.01%, then in the world today there are over half a million people just as bright as you; enough to make a small city. No matter how smart you think you or your clique are, there is a city of smarter people out there. Now this is the rub - the city couldn't exist anyway. The problem is that unless you exist in a true meritocracy most of these brilliant people are unlikely to be discovered. I believe I've met many outstandingly intelligent and thoughtful people who, because of the cards that life has dealt them, have never come close to realising their potential. A true meritocracy needs to hunt out these individuals.

So what do we live in; isn't the internet a true meritocracy? Well, it seems closer to a "shoutocracy" or, not to mix languages, a Stentorocracy (from the greek hero with the big lungs) than to a true meritocracy. There are those who argue the "wisdom of the crowd" creates a meritocracy. However the crowd is equally wise as daft (see Marquis de Condorcet for a more formal examination of this). You also still have to shout at the crowd and then you have the problem of memes.

So anyway back to the book. It led me to a group called the Edge. It's an interesting mix of self-selecting cultural imperialism, combined with some ardent beliefs and pleasurable intellectual discourse. Now there is nothing wrong with this - it's a talking shop - but the claims it makes are somewhat disturbing. It's not so much the edge, as sailing close or over it.

  • "The third culture consists of those scientists and other thinkers in the empirical world who, through their work and expository writing, are taking the place of the traditional intellectual in rendering visible the deeper meanings of our lives, redefining who and what we are."

All hail to the priesthood. Hmmm, Hume would be turning in his grave - where has the humility gone?

  • "America now is the intellectual seedbed for Europe and Asia."
  • "The emergence of the third culture introduces new modes of intellectual discourse and reaffirms the preeminence of America in the realm of important ideas"

All hail to the imperium! I think 6 billion people might disagree with this. This doesn't mean the ideas or people aren't interesting, the claims are just a tad strong though.

  • "Who are the 'digerati' and why are they 'the cyber elite'? They are the doers, thinkers, and writers who have tremendous influence on the emerging communication revolution. They are not on the frontier, they are the frontier."

All hail to the Kings and Queens. They may well be self-anointed, but let the meme spread long enough and soon the crowd in its wisdom will be chanting. Still, it could be worse :-

King Arthur: I am your king.
Serf: Well I didn't vote for you.
King Arthur: You don't vote for kings.
Serf: Well how'd you become king then?
King Arthur: The Lady of the Lake, her arm clad in the purest shimmering samite held aloft Excalibur from the bosom of the water, signifying by divine providence that I, Arthur, was to carry Excalibur. THAT is why I am your king.
Serf: Listen, strange women lyin' in ponds distributin' swords is no basis for a system of government. Supreme executive power derives from a mandate from the masses, not from some farcical aquatic ceremony.
Serf: You can't expect to wield supreme executive power just because some watery tart threw a sword at you.
Serf: If I went 'round sayin' I was Emperor, just because some moistened bint lobbed a scimitar at me, they'd put me away.
(Monty Python, Holy Grail ... if you haven't seen this, you should)

and finally ...

  • "The role of the intellectual includes communicating. Intellectuals are not just people who know things but people who shape the thoughts of their generation. An intellectual is a synthesizer, a publicist, a communicator."

Ah, the Stentorocracy in action, the pantomisation of science (oh no it isn't, oh yes it is - I can't hear you!) - this is as dangerous a meme or idea as any in the book. Still, it's an interesting book - worth reading and it won't make you go blind.

249 comments:

«Oldest   ‹Older   201 – 249 of 249
UK Dissertation Help said...

Hello Guys, Whole purpose of the Marketing Dissertation Help services is to form a product or service and explain the whole procedure of popularizing it within the trade and business business. Your selling thesis should be good because the business is continually changing and moving ahead. There are many students who stumble into having too big a marketing dissertation or having it too narrow.

Edward Lewis said...

Nice one! thank you so much! Thank you for sharing this post.

trendmicro.com/activation
trendmicro.com/activation

msofficesetups said...

Nice Post....
Are you facing too much complexity in the context of implementing the office set up key? Well, you should not need to worry and take the full association of our technical team as some chaos come in your business production availability. Making the solid improvement in the compatible items available at www.office.com/setup is obvious so that you cannot be stone throw distance for attaining the most positive result. Let us consult to our technical team in case you are feeling some technical abnormalities in this application. There is no need to move here and there and consult to our expert for reporting the problem. Our troubleshooting skills are so good that any customer does not give too much trouble to customer. Lastly, it is good to come on our third party professional to sort out technical issue. Feel free to contact us our team.

Alexclara75 said...

central.bitdefender.com

avast.com/activate

central.bitdefender.com

webroot.com/safe

john amber said...

Thank you for this wonderful information looking forward for more. We are Providing the best quality assignment help. You will find out online accounting Assignment Help service on firstassignmenthelp. And these services are very reliable, and they can provide information about any topic related to the academics. If you need any college level Assignment Help at reliable quality with better work. Kindly visit our website firstassignmenthelp.

msofficesetups said...

Nice Post...
Hi, I am Dayna Martin as an Office tech support executive well praise amongst the customer to help out them in resolve their queries related to office setup. As problem or queries can turn up at anytime so you should be ready for it, just visit office.com/setup and download the most recent office setup. While doing so if you come crosswise any complexity then you can make association with me.

لمار ابراهيم said...

شركة نقل عفش من جدة الى بيشة
شركة نقل عفش من جدة الى محايل عسير
شركة نقل عفش من جدة الى جازان
شركة نقل عفش من جدة الى الباحة
شركة نقل عفش واثاث من جدة الى حائل
شركة نقل عفش واثاث من جدة الي الرياض
شركة نقل عفش من جدة الى الدمام
نقل عفش من جده الى القطيف
نقل عفش من جده الى جازان







Raj Kumar Singh said...

This Article is Really Fantastic And Thanks For Sharing The Valuable Post..Issues With Quicken Software Dial Or Visit Quicken Technical Support Phone Number Get Instant Help and Support from Quicken Certified Experts.You Do Not Want To Get Hold Of The Quicken Support Online Or Be Looking For Opening Hours For Quicken Support Team.

Indian Travel Store said...

Thank You Author!!! You are sharing the very informative and great post.
If anyone out there is looking to book kerala tour packages from hyderabad then don’t go beyond Indian Travel Store – “Your Trusted Partner in your Travel Journey.”

Raj Kumar Singh said...

This Article is Really Fantastic And Thanks For Sharing The Valuable Post..Issues With Quicken Software Dial Or Visit Quicken Technical Support Phone Number Get Instant Help and Support from Quicken Certified Experts.You Do Not Want To Get Hold Of The Quicken Support Online Or Be Looking For Opening Hours For Quicken Support Team.

Raj Kumar Singh said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Alex Smith said...

Thank you so much for sharing such superb information's with us. Download the Microsoft Office setup on your Windows or Mac computer. Make sure that the Office product key is already copied for the activation procedure. office.com/setup mcafee.com/activate|office.com/setup

Alex Smith said...

Activating McAfee is a quick and simple process. You just need to copy your 25 characters alphanumeric product key and paste it in the activation tab. Let’s check out the step-by-step process #mcafee #activate mcafee.com/activate | mcafee.com/activate | mcafee.com/activate | mcafee.com/activate

Expo 2020 said...

Hope you will keep on offering good content like this more often. I feel more and more people should know about this. Also, I agree on most of the points you have made.
Places to visit In Dubai

pesh said...

Thank you for sharing great content. Will be your occasional visitor. Drip Irrigation is a kind of micro-irrigation system that delivers water slowly at a low pressure near or at the root zone of the plants. Get Best drip emitters today

josee said...

Thank you for sharing great content. Will be your occasional visitor. Drip Irrigation is a kind of micro-irrigation system that delivers water slowly at a low pressure near or at the root zone of the plants. Get Best drip emitters today

London Tiger Security said...

Amazing article. Your blog helped me to improve myself in many ways thanks for sharing this kind of wonderful informative blogs in live. I have bookmarked more article from this website. If someone wants to know about Security Services Company this is the right place for you..

Security Services

James Marcus said...

Thanks for your valuable post. Please post some more related topics. We are on your page only to read your blog because, as you know, there are no other for being here. Like you, we also here for some information of Outlook, so if any of you need any type of help related Outlook then contact our Outlook support phone number or visit the website.
Is there a phone number for Outlook support?
How do I contact outlook by phone?
Outlook customer service number
Outlook customer service

Alex Smith said...

Thank you so much for sharing such superb information's with us. Download the Microsoft Office setup on your Microsoft application provides a better way to access information, and consequently, users can have greater insight, and they can manage most of their essential work with more productivity and in less time. office.com/setup mcafee.com/activate|office.com/setup

Alex Smith said...

McAfee Activate – Get robust protection by downloading and installing the McAfee antivirus. Go to McAfee Activate and enter the product key to activate your McAfee product #mcafee #activate mcafee.com/activate | mcafee.com/activate | mcafee.com/activate | mcafee.com/activate

w-nortoncomnorton said...

Secluded Purchase:- In the pulled back get, one can without a major proportion of a stretch buy the Norton Setup thing from the nearest retail store. Customer will get a CD close retail card having incitation code on it. Show the Norton.com/Setup from the CD and start it by the printed incitation key.

alexathomson said...

Thank you for sharing this interesting article, It was quite informative and looking for more such article from your end. We do have a article on printers. If you have any issue related to printers then you can contact or visit our websites and we will be happy to help you out.
Canon printer support

officecomoffice-office said...

You share a awesome information…
Avast customer support phone number +1-855-619-5888 Call us and remain ensured while taking a shot at your PC, The technical customer care support for Avast can be availed by dialing. http://avast-avast.com
Avast customer support number
Avast support Number

officecomoffice-office said...

You share a piece of awesome information…
MS office Installing and Activating process: Read all of them taking into account guidelines of www.office.com/setup and follow some easy steps resolution knocked out to activate and to install MS Office easily in your MAC/Laptops and PC http://officeoffice-us.com
office.com/setup
www.office.com/setup

officecomoffice-office said...

I appreciate your post, Please Keep posting with more information…
Norton setup is a protect all your devices with your Norton help, Norton setup is a makes it easy for you to set up in www.norton.com/setup your PC from viruses protection, quickly check and remove virus from your PC to easily, http://nortoncomnortonnorton.com
www.NorTon.com/setup
Norton.com/setup

officecomoffice-office said...

Thanks for sharing this useful information...
Process for the setup of Norton from www.norton.com/setup, Go to the Norton Site for setup, download, reinstall is my norton.com/setup where you can enter and activate your product key and set up your account successfully. https://wwwnorton-norton.com/
Norton setup
www.norton.com/setup

Arya_stark's Blogs said...


Thanks For sharing with us this importent Content. I feel strongly about it and really enjoyed learning more about this topic.


Avast.com/activate | Avast.com/activate |trendmicro.com/activation | trendmicro.com/activation

Indian Travel Store said...

Thank You Author!!! You are sharing the very informative and great post.
If anyone out there is looking to book Cheapest Kerala Tour Packages for Couple with Best Price then don’t go beyond Indian Travel Store – “Your Trusted Partner in your Travel Journey.”

Raj Kumar Singh said...

This Article is Really Fantastic And Thanks For Sharing The Valuable Post..Issues With Quicken Software Dial Or Visit Quicken Online Backup Support Get Instant Help and Support from Quicken Certified Experts.You Do Not Want To Get Hold Of The Quicken Support Online Or Be Looking For Opening Hours For Quicken Support Team.

ireland assignment help said...

Best assignment writers are always online at Ireland Assignment Help for offering the assignment help online to students and complete their assignment without missing the deadline. Our professional writers can write assignments outstandingly provided to the students by their professors.

Raj Kumar Singh said...

This Article is Really Fantastic And Thanks For Sharing The Valuable Post..Issues With Quicken Software Dial Or Visit Quicken Accounting Services Get Instant Help and Support from Quicken Certified Experts.You Do Not Want To Get Hold Of The Quicken Support Online Or Be Looking For Opening Hours For Quicken Support Team.

finnjordan100 said...

Webroot makes sure that you have the best security software products installed on your computer, it uses antivirus protection and a firewall, gives antispyware software, always keeps it up to date.
www.webroot.com/secure | webroot.com/secure | Install Webroot With Key Code

Mark William said...

Trend Micro is an industry leader in antivirus protection and internet security, with 30 years of security software experience in keeping millions of users safe trend micro download Security secures your connected world providing protection against malware, ransomware, spyware, and cyber threats that could compromise your online experience. www.trendmicro.com/downloadme It also helps protect you from identity theft, viruses, online scams, and other emerging threats.

lily grace said...

webroot com safe is the right page to download your webroot product. A user may directly download webroot program from this page without creating a webroot account. Although creating an account is still a better alternative as you can login to your webroot account and get your product anywhere and can install on any device. Also if you somehow lose your antivirus somehow , you just need to login to your account and you can recover your software from that place. Details for creating an account in given above just after the top section. www.webroot.com/safe |

webroot.com/safe
Install Webroot With Key Code

ameliasmith010 said...

OK prefer to present avg.com/retail with your license key code? To begin with, you need to guarantee that there are no other security programs presented in your working system then you have completed the activation methodology you can sign in to your AVG Account and go to the enrollment territory of your record and a short time later you can see the catch there like Add device. Directly you can start to begin the download and foundation of your www.avg.com/retail thing on the web.

You may face the avg error while updating the avg antivirus. Connect with our executives by dial 1-800-570-3215

www.avg.com/retail
avg http server returned error
avg error code 0xc007001c and 0xc007643
avg error 0xe001f94e
avg error code oxe001c046
avg antivirus error code 0xe001d027

rachel joy said...

Trend Micro is best antivirus in this field because it uses multi-layered ransomware protection by working in three directions.
www.trendmicro.com/bestbuypc |Trend Micro Geek Squad | www.trendmicro/bestbuypc | Trend Micro Geek Squad

rachel joy said...

AVG AntiVirus Free provides the same core virus protection as the Pro edition, some peripheral services are missing, when compared to the 'Pro' version.
www.avg.com/retail | avg.com/retail

Unknown said...

Nice Blog, I love your blog and your way of thinking. Usually, you write for the different topic but I also request you that you also write on traveling. I also have a website for HP Printer, so please visit and check my website as well as content. Printer Is Offline Window 10 and the printer is offline are my main keywords.
Also, get help on Printer Is Offline Window 10 and ask for related queries about Printer.
HP printer is printing
HP Printer Offline Window 10

Fainahassan said...

TurboTax is one of the most commonly used income tax preparation software package. There are different versions including TurboTax Deluxe, Turbo Tax Premier etc. TurboTax is available for both federal and state income tax returns. Sometimes, users face certain technical issues like login issue, software installation etc. Reach our turbotax support team today and get instant help from our team of experts.

finnjordan100 said...

Webroot makes sure that you have the best security software products installed on your computer, it uses antivirus protection and a firewall, gives antispyware software, always keeps it up to date.
www.webroot.com/secure | webroot.com/secure | Install Webroot With Key Code

finnjordan100 said...

AVG Secure is designed to keep your digital info safe and secure. Learn about its pricing, security features, and more in this review.

www.avg.com/retail | avg.com/retail | Install AVG with license number | AVG Download | www.avg.com/activation

lily grace said...

webroot com safe is the right page to download your webroot product. A user may directly download webroot program from this page without creating a webroot account. Although creating an account is still a better alternative as you can login to your webroot account and get your product anywhere and can install on any device. Also if you somehow lose your antivirus somehow , you just need to login to your account and you can recover your software from that place. Details for creating an account in given above just after the top section. www.webroot.com/safe |

webroot.com/safe |
Install Webroot With Key Code

lily grace said...

This antivirus program is so light and easy to install, you and your family will be protected in just moments. It’ll then keep protecting you day and night, automatically updating itself against the latest threats to help keep you and your family safe. www.avg.com/retail | www.avg.com/activation
avg activation
avg.com/activation

Assignment Help Australia said...

Assignment Help Australia services are the best options to submit pending assignments on time without taking stress of missing due dates. Check out our website for more information about online academic writing services in Australia.
Assignment Help
Assignment Help Online
Online Assignment Help
Australia Assignment Help
Assignment Helper
Assignment Assistance
Assignment Help Experts
Online Assignment Help Services

Mark William said...

Trend Micro Internet Security subscription is the single way to download the software on multiple devices through www.trendmicro.com/downloadme . Trend micro has become a superior antivirus program over many antiviruses due to its advanced protection features. trend micro download process becomes easy when you purchase the subscription. But when the subscription expires, the user needs to renew it; otherwise, it won’t protect your device anymore. In this blog, we will discuss how you can renew your Trend Micro Internet Security subscription.


lily grace said...

Webroot stability package is very straightforward to setup & install webroot.com/safe. Locate a code that's written in the backside of the card. This Might Be an Example Product Essential to let you know. www.webroot.com/safe |

webroot.com/safe |
Install Webroot With Key Code

finnjordan100 said...


Webroot, a Carbonite company, harnesses the cloud and machine learning to reliably predict and protect against cyberattacks in real time.
www.webroot.com/secure | webroot.com/secure | Install Webroot With Key Code

Mark William said...

Trend Micro Internet Security subscription is the single way to download the software on multiple devices through www.trendmicro.com/downloadme . Trend micro has become a superior antivirus program over many antiviruses due to its advanced protection features. trend micro download process becomes easy when you purchase the subscription. But when the subscription expires, the user needs to renew it; otherwise, it won’t protect your device anymore. In this blog, we will discuss how you can renew your Trend Micro Internet Security subscription.

Tom Parker said...

AVG Secure is designed to keep your digital info safe and secure. Learn about its pricing, security features, and more in this review.

www.avg.com/retail |www.avg.com/activate | AVG Download | avg.com/retail

«Oldest ‹Older   201 – 249 of 249   Newer› Newest»